Pong Kombat 2: Picking apart a game we made when we were 16 years old.

In the summer of 1996, my best friend Arturo and myself decided to make a sequel to Pong Kombat. While that was over 15 years ago, the experience provided an immense amount of insight into game design and development.

Pong Kombat 2

Picture this: summer in Florida with only 3 months of school left, we would skip school and work on our game. I remember acting that I was walking to the bus stop. I reached a certain house, cut through, and hid in our backyard, behind the air conditioner unit. I pulled a pillow out of my backpack and got comfortable. I knew it would be about an hour before both of my parents left.

Ryan Sadwick and Arturo Aquino sitting next to pong kombat 2

Finally, I heard the last car leave. I opened up the window to my bedroom, climbed through, and left all my school materials behind in my room. Now it was time to work on Pong Kombat 2! Arturo would show up soon, so I opened up our project file, which was developed with Klik N’ Play.

Game Development

We would order a large pizza and drink loads of Sprite. Developing on full stomach and sugar was our ritual to draw up all of our ideas: the story continuing from the original game, each of the new paddles, all the secrets, and the backgrounds of each character. Yes, Pong Kombat 2 is truly developed on a kitchen counter by two 16 year olds.

Ryan Sadwick and Arturo Aquino about to play basketball.

At that time, we had a decent amount of tools. We used trueSpace 2 for all our animation, background art, and logos. We used Photoshop for text effects, clean up, and editing. For sound effects – the blood that shoots out of the paddles… those were all home made sounds: the blood effect was a ketchup bottle being squeezed with some pitch amplifying using Sound Forge.

Tornado level in Pong Kombat 2.

That’s right, we both were animating, programming, creating sound effects: the whole package. All in one hybrids that would skip school to write computer games. Those were the days!

Time to really name the game

Honestly, we wrote this entire game without asking the original author’s permission. Well, keep in mind, we were only 16 years old at the time… we didn’t know any better but in the back of my mind, I thought it would be best if we did. All I remember is I typed out a letter, signed it, and snail mailed it to Stefan Gagne. I kept my fingers crossed that he’d say “yes” and I wouldn’t have to rename the game.

I got an e-mail a few weeks later. While he wasn’t entirely happy we didn’t ask him first… he was impressed that we wrote up a storyline and put forth all this work into making a sequel. He granted us a license to release Pong Kombat 2.

Arturo Aquino and Ryan Sadwick posing next to the lava level in Pong Kombat 2.

The Release

Life was good. We tested the game and added in little bells and whistles. (actually those bells and whistles were tagging on more and more megabytes). The release candidate was around 20mb, which was HUGE for an Indie, down-loadable game, back then. I contacted all my favorite Bulletin Board Systems (BBS) and all of them were happy to host the game. I also had contacted AOL’s download center. AOL also agreed to host the game too.

A week and almost 5 months after the release, we received thousands e-mails about the game: mostly good things. Some were bad saying our game “sucked”. That’s cool though, there was no way we could please everyone.

Arturo Aquino and Ryan Sadwick showing all the emails and design documents for Pong Kombat 2.

The above image shows Art will a folder full of printed e-mails and snail mails we received. I’m holding up the design document folder.

Play It Now

I play the game now and realize… wow, it’s not the greatest game. There is a mountain of aspects that damage the game. I’m sure we didn’t realize this at the time, we were having fun and it was our first game. Here is what I found:

Arturo Aquino and Ryan Sadwick posing next to the lava level in Pong Kombat 2.

If you wait long enough on the title screen, you get to see the story.

It’s very difficult unless you cheat

The first few levels are okay but once you get to stages that have 2-4 balls going at once and your opponent is shooting out stuff at you: there is too much going on to manage.

I can feel that the upper stages were not tuned at all, they’re just rough and unforgiving. I must have just added in extra balls to make sure no one could beat it?

Tornado level in Pong Kombat 2 with Shifter.

If you wait long enough on the title screen, you get to see the story.

Lava level in Pong Kombat 2 with Shifter and Magma paddle.

Cheat? Yes, there are overpowered Paddles you can choose and steamroll the game in minutes. What? You didn’t know that? More on that later.

The specials moves: you have to look up the key combos and remember.

PK2 is a parody off Mortal Kombat and Pong… but I know I can come up with a better way of designing the controls. Back then, we used PK1 as the example, which in turn used the Mortal Kombat controls. Those controls just don’t translate well on the keyboard as they do on a gamepad.

So what ends up happening here is you have to print out the manual (same goes for the cheat guide) or write down the moves. I don’t mind games that provide a manual but that’s not the first thing I want to do with a new game… I’d rather play it first!

The AI can cheese you.

You might start noticing when you hit the ball, sometimes it goes directly to the opponent! The cool part is, your adversary slow down to return the ball back. Cheesy? Extra cheese! I don’t recall the intervals where the opponents fire their special weapons but it was increased as you progressed. That seems okay.

an arrow showing why the ball was not programmed well.

The last boss, White Paddle spams you with his fireballs. That was actually intentional! The strategy to beat him is to keep hitting the ball and dodging the fireballs… White Paddle isn’t good at actually hitting the ball. Cool strategy but how many deaths (no continue option) could you chalk up before figuring that one out?

Pong: the ball

The ball itself doesn’t follow proper physics, which leads to another problem: you’ll notice sometimes the ball will bounce from the bottom to the top of the screen over and over… and can be extremely annoying, especially when you slide your paddle and smack the ball. You expect the ball to move in that direction. We should have played around with the AI more and come up with some physics.

A path drawn showing why the ball would path in bad places.

Playing matches where the ball just acts like this is just plain boring.

A path drawn from top to bottom illustrating why the ball would get stuck.

Sometimes the ball will just bounce up and down right next to you. It eventually stops this but still…

Many times, the ball can get stuck behind your paddle or the opponent. Losing or winning a match like that feels so wrong. That could have been easily fixed.

The menus: you had to use a mouse and click the options

A game that uses the keyboard as the main controls… you should be able to select the menu options with the keyboard arrows… not just the mouse. Feels weird.

A path drawn from top to bottom illustrating why the ball would get stuck.

Reboot and Quit Game are the first two options? Nice!

The options screen sucks. There really isn’t any options. There are more options in the debug menu. However, the option screen follows Mortal Kombat option screens: lack of options unless you used codes to unlock more options.

Way too many secrets

The verses screen that shows the match puzzle.

What the heck do those symbols mean? I don’t remember.

There are so many, many, many secrets in the game which in turn are extremely difficult if not impossible to access. The design document says 92 secrets. That is insane. Maybe we were thinking “replay” value?

The best secret is the built in debug menu where you can simply choose a “super secret paddle” and run through the game. Or choose the “secret paddle menu” and pick “Awesome Paddle”, who takes up the entire screen and never misses a ball!

A screenshot of Awesome Paddle.

Awesome Paddle took up the whole screen… dude lived up to his name.

Fighting a secret paddle: a match against Art Paddle or Wacky Paddle (the stars have to align perfectly to unlock Wacky) is nearly impossible. It’s almost equivalent to fighting Jade or Smoke in Mortal Kombat 2… except with even more downright cheap and punishing difficulty. I’m sure that was intended though.

Debug Menu in Pong Kombat 2
The great Cigarette Paddle. You can shoot smoke… now that is awesome.
Yea, we even had our own version of “Toasty!”

Still, we’re happy about the game

Even with all these call outs I’ve made on this game, I’m proud that my name is on it. We put a lot of hard work into the game. We didn’t have all the resources in the world but when I play it now, I can tell it was made with a lot of love.

Does this mean it’s time for a remake? Maybe when the time is right, I’ll sit down and rewrite the whole game but make it extremely fun like the original one was, keeping these points in mind.